Posted by Anne M on Tuesday, Apr 3, 2012
I admit it: I like celebrating anniversaries. Whether it's for Dickens' 200th birthday or the 150th anniversary of the Civil War, I mark the dates with a book or a documentary. However, due to a certain film by a certain director, I wasn't interested in the 100th anniversary of the sinking of the Titanic (April 15th). As far as I was concerned, the Titanic was at the bottom of the ocean. End of story. After stumbling upon Andrew Wilson's Shadow of the Titanic, I've changed my mind.
Rather than providing an account of the sinking of the Titanic or a history of its building and demise, Wilson focuses on the people who survived the disaster and how the event was a turning point in their lives. Some, like Renee Harris, Madeleine Astor, and Marian Thayer, lost their husbands; J. Bruce Ismay and Sir Cosmo Duff Gordon lost their reputations. Silent film actress Dorothy Gibson survived the sinking, but had to relive the whole experience when she starred in Saved from the Titanic, a film made days after the disaster by Jules Brulatour, who also happened to be Gibson's lover. (That relationship didn't last long.) What is fascinating is how some used the experience to change their lives and work for something, while others found the Titanic a black mark that they couldn't escape. Of course, all the stories are noticeably those of first-class women.
There are times when I wish Wilson held back. He would often surmise what individuals were thinking or what their priorities were with little evidence, making harsh judgments on certain survivors. However, it is an interesting and surprising approach to the Titanic's history.
You can mark the anniversary of the sinking of the Titanic by picking up Shadow of the Titanic (or the thirty other books we own). The library is also showing A Night to Remember (1958) on Thursday, April 12th at 7 pm in Meeting Room A.
As Bilger asserts in his family memoir, Fatherland, everyone will find something haunting in their own family tree. His own is his grandfather. Karl Gönner, a member of the Nazi party and schoolteacher was sent to Alsace in occupied France to "reeducate" the children of Bartenheim. He was promoted to head of the Nazi party in the town overseeing required work assignments. Grappling with this information, Bilger returns to the region, researching and seeking what his grandfather did, trying to find why he would participate. With all of these things, it's complicated. Bilger writes thoughtfully and openly, taking on a painful, hurtful subject. -Anne M